News / LGBTQI Rights

Open letter: Call to uphold constitutional commitments and vote against resolution to suspend work of UN expert on sexual orientation and gender identity

Dear Honourable Ministers Nkoana-Mashabane and Masutha, Ambassador Mxakato-Diseko, and Honourable Members of the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on International Relations and Cooperation


We are deeply disappointed and confused by the Department of International Relations and Cooperation’s (DIRCO) apparent support for a resolution and accompanying African Group statement, calling for the suspension of the UN Human Rights Council’s appointment of the Independent Expert on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity (SOGI). This statement was lodged by Botswana at the Third Committee of the General Assembly, on behalf of the Africa Group, of which South Africa is a member, on Friday 4 November 2016. This statement called for “the suspension of the activities of the appointed Independent Expert pending the determination of this issue”. In addition, the statement stated that sexual orientation and gender identity “are not and should not be linked to existing international human rights instruments”.

We strongly disagree with this position, given South Africa’s constitutional and international law obligations, and commitment to equality and nondiscrimination on the basis of any status.

In 2011 South Africa itself introduced a SOGI resolution, which received wide support with 23 votes in favour. In March 2016 DIRCO signed what is known as the Ekhuruleni Declaration, on practical measures to combat violence against LGBTIQ+ persons on the African continent. Then, in July 2016 the South African delegation abstained from a vote to appoint the Special Rapporteur on SOGI, at the 32nd Session of the Human Rights Council. Civil society made its strong disapproval known, and demanded an explanation. Now the African Group statement clearly states that sexual orientation and gender identity are “non-internationally agreed notions” that are entirely unlinked to international human rights instruments. This statement is presented as the consensus position of the Africa Group, and South Africa has failed to disassociate itself from it. These events appear to indicate that South Africa is steadily moving away from progressive human rights norms.

The notion that the mandate of the Independent Expert would compromise the right to development and anti-racism is incorrect, given that the SOGI mandate is inherently intersectional, and undertakes to strengthen the mechanisms addressing issues of importance, including fighting racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance in all their forms. As is the case with all Special Rapporteurs, the Independent Expert is not mandated to interfere with national jurisdiction, but instead to engage states in dialogue and support the implementation of existing international human rights instruments.

The international community have voiced strong condemnation of South Africa’s position, as stated in the African Group statement. We, the South African organisations championing the rights of the LGBTIQ+ community, and members of that community, hereby add our voices to this condemnation.

We urge the South African delegation to vote against the upcoming resolution tabled by the African Group. Failure to do so will severely damage the LGBTIQ+ sector’s confidence in our government’s stated commitment to protecting and championing SOGI rights, and will compromise South Africa’s reputation as an African leader in this regard.  It will also fundamentally undermine South Africa’s commitment to the institutional integrity of the Human Rights Council, a body to which South Africa just sought re-election.

Yours faithfully,

  • Access Chapter 2
  • Centre for Applied Legal Studies
  • Gay & Lesbian Network, Pietermaritzburg
  • Gay and Lesbian Memory in Action
  • Gender Dynamix
  • Gender, Health and Justice Research Unit, University of Cape Town
  • Iranti-org
  • Lawyers for Human Rights
  • Sex Worker Education and Advocacy Taskforce
  • Sonke Gender Justice
  • Southern Africa Litigation Centre
  • Treatment Action Campaign, Western Cape
  • Triangle Project
  • Women’s Legal Centre


Hate Crimes Working Group Chair: Sanja Bornman (Lawyers for Human Rights), 083 522 2933
Hate Crimes Working Group Secretary: Matthew Clayton (Triangle Project), 082 828 5275

9 November 2016
You may also like
Civil society organisations disappointed by failure of Ministry of Police to respond to SAHRC regarding xenophobic state…
7 Dec 17 – We call on the Ministry of Police to respond to the SAHRC’s letter with urgency, and …
Sonke releases 10 year anniversary video and latest Annual Report on heels of important human rights achievements
5 Dec 17 – Celebrating a decade of working to advance gender justice in South Africa and the region.
Sonke Gender Justice welcomes UNAIDS World AIDS Day report on the urgent need to reach men and boys with HIV services
1 Dec 17 – Sonke calls on governments around the world and especially in Southern and Eastern Africa, to act …
Sonke welcomes passing of Labour Laws Amendment Bill as landmark achievement for all parents in South Africa
29 Nov 17 – Sonke welcomes the acceptance of the Labour Laws Amendment Bill by the National Assembly on Tuesday …
Sonke reiterates call for Mduduzi Manana’s removal from parliament
15 Nov 17 – Sonke notes with grave concern that Mr Manana continues to serve as a member of parliament. …
Sonke stands by the women who accused Danny Jordaan of rape and call for him to be held accountable
3 Nov 17 – Sonke calls for Jordaan to be suspended from the ANC and as SAFA president with immediate …
Victory for child rights and violence prevention in South Africa as defence of reasonable chastisement ruled out of line…
20 Oct 17 – The South Gauteng High Court has ruled that parents charged with hitting their children will no …
Sonke calls for apology and retraction from King Goodwill Zwelithini regarding recent comments on corporal punishment
4 Oct 17 – Calling for a renewed commitment from the Department of Basic Education to implement the National Protocol …
“We must have zero tolerance for all forms of violence”
3 Oct 17 – Outlining the necessity of the Five Days of Violence Prevention Conference.

Send this to a friend